Showing posts with label Karl Popper. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Karl Popper. Show all posts

Monday, February 15, 2021

"Everything Is Connected, Nothing Happens Without a Reason, and Nothing Is as It Appears"

"When you have trained yourself to believe that you are self-sufficient, that you are the source of your health… when a public health official comes around and says 'Actually, you may be an asymptomatic carrier of a disease that you're not aware of', that's really insulting,' says Mr Remski."

At BBC News, Joshua Cheetham asks, "Does yoga have a conspiracy theory problem?"

And at the CBC, Nahlah Ayed asks, "Are conspiracy theories really 'a new religion'?"

Saturday, February 13, 2021

"We Are Constantly Told to 'Trust the Science,' but What Does That Mean If We Cannot Quite Tell Where or What the Science Is?"

"It is not quite sufficient, in answering this question, to point to a near-consensus on the part of the scientific community, thus in effect arguing that science is what the vast majority of scientists say it is. If this is largely how the argument does indeed function in the cases of debates about the safety of vaccines or the causes of global warming, we should nonetheless be aware of its flaws. Scientific revolutions, after all, involve rejections of scientific orthodoxy by a committed minority. If many anti-vaxxers or climate-change denialists appear more like Venkman than Galileo, it is nonetheless Galileo's mantle that they seek. We're back to Popper's problem: is there an in-principle way of distinguishing a revolutionary from a dedicated flim-flam artist that doesn't assume the correctness of either position in advance?"

Suman Seth at the Los Angeles Review of Books reviews Michael D. Gordin's On the Fringe: Where Science Meets Pseudoscience.