"America Isn't the Church and the Church Isn't America"

"Winthrop got close to getting the analogy right because he called the Puritans to follow and reflect biblical teachings about charity and mercy as they followed Christ. His shortcoming, as seen by the Puritan breakdown over the next few decades, was thinking that a whole society could possibly do that well over the long term. Reagan's vision of America being a city on a hill wasn't terrible because he was simply building off of biblical imagery to make a point about the goodness and potential example of our country, but it still falls far short of what the saying really means."

At The Bulwark, Alan Cross writes that "America Cannot Be the Biblical City on a Hill."